Sofa cleaning

Carpet care guide

Steam cleaning vs dry carpet cleaning: an honest comparison

Steam cleaning and dry cleaning are everyday names for two families of carpet cleaning methods. One rinses the carpet with hot water. The other uses very little water. Each has a job it does well. This guide compares them plainly and lists its sources.

By Ridgeline Carpet Cleaning · Updated

First, the names

Steam cleaning is the common name for hot water extraction. No steam is involved. The machine sprays hot water and a cleaning agent into the carpet, then vacuums the water back out together with the loosened soil. Wikipedia's carpet cleaning article describes it as "sometimes mistakenly called" steam cleaning.

Dry carpet cleaning is not fully dry either. It is a loose name for several low-moisture methods that use a little liquid, a foam or a damp compound where the other method uses a water rinse.

The low-moisture methods

  • Encapsulation. A solution that contains polymers is brushed into the carpet. As it dries, it turns into a brittle residue around the soil, and the residue is vacuumed away. Drying takes about 20 to 30 minutes.
  • Bonnet cleaning. A machine scrubs the top of the carpet with an absorbent pad, and the pad takes up the soil it loosens. It is not strictly dry cleaning.
  • Dry compound. An absorbent cleaning compound is spread over the carpet, brushed in and vacuumed out.
  • Shampoo. A rotary machine scrubs a foaming detergent into the pile. When there is no rinse, residue stays in the carpet and keeps collecting dirt.

Very low moisture and dry compound systems dry fast. That is why they are common in commercial buildings, where a floor cannot stay closed for long.

Side by side

MethodWhat it does wellLimitsDrying
Hot water extractionRinses soil and cleaning solution out of the pile. It is the method carpet makers name.Uses the most water. Needs strong extraction and air flow afterward.Hours. See drying times.
EncapsulationQuick upkeep of lightly soiled carpet with little downtime.No water rinse. The residue has to be vacuumed out later.About 20 to 30 minutes
BonnetA fast lift for the surface.Works on the surface, not the base of the pile.Short
Dry compoundRooms that have to stay in use.All of the compound has to be vacuumed back out.Short
Shampoo with no rinseScrubbing action on matted soil.Leaves residue that keeps collecting dirt.Varies

What carpet makers ask for

The large carpet makers take a side. Shaw's care page tells owners to schedule professional hot water extraction, which it also calls steam cleaning. A Shaw stain warranty we read wants "proof of periodic cleaning by hot water extraction" when a claim is filed. Mohawk's residential care guide says Mohawk requires that method every 18 months, using products, equipment or systems that carry the Seal of Approval of the Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI).

The Seal of Approval is CRI's own program. CRI says cleaners in the program are "recommended and sometimes required by the manufacturer." Warranties differ, so read yours. The intervals are in how often to clean carpet.

Truck-mounted and portable machines

Hot water extraction is done with one of two kinds of machine. This is how the two types work in general.

What differsTruck-mountedPortable
Where the machine sitsIn the van. Only the hoses come inside.It is carried into the home.
Heat and vacuumMade by the vehicle or a separate engine.Runs on household power.
Water and wasteDirty water goes to a tank in the van.Both are held in tanks on the machine.
Where it is usedHomes the hoses can reach from the street or driveway.Upper-floor apartments and condos, and some gated or high-rise buildings.

Wikipedia notes that for large jobs a truck mount "may be faster and more effective than portable equipment." Either type can do good work. Much depends on the rinse, the extraction and the care taken. If access to your home is tight, say so when we call to confirm your visit. Ridgeline Carpet Cleaning uses a portable machine.

What IICRC and the S100 standard are

IICRC stands for Institute of Inspection Cleaning and Restoration Certification. It describes itself as a non-profit organization for the inspection, cleaning and restoration industries. It was founded in 1972 as the International Institute of Carpet and Upholstery Cleaning.

IICRC credentials come in two kinds. A Certified Technician is a person. A Certified Firm is a company. IICRC reports more than 49,000 active Certified Technicians and more than 6,500 Certified Firms. When a cleaner mentions IICRC, ask which of the two it means.

ANSI/IICRC S100 is the Standard for Professional Cleaning of Textile Floor Coverings. In IICRC's words, it "describes the procedures, methods, and systems to be followed" when carpet and rugs are cleaned in homes and businesses. The current edition is the seventh, from 2021, and a revision is under way. The standard is sold, not posted, so we do not quote from it.

This section explains terms you will meet when you compare cleaners. It says nothing about the credentials of any company, ours included.

Which one fits your carpet

  • A home carpet due for a deep clean. Hot water extraction is the usual choice, and it is the method the warranty documents above name.
  • An office or store between deep cleanings. Low-moisture upkeep puts the floor back in service fast. See commercial carpet cleaning.
  • Pet urine. Heat is the wrong first step. CRI warns that a steam cleaner on a urine spot sets the stain and the smell, so the spot is treated before any hot rinse. See pet stain and odor removal.
  • Wool. It needs wool-safe products, cooler water, less moisture and fast drying. See wool carpet and rug care.
  • Delicate area rugs. The fiber decides, and some rugs should not be wet cleaned at home. See area rug cleaning.

Our own carpet service is hot water extraction. We look at the carpet with you first, because wool, pet spots and delicate fibers change the steps.

Quick answers

Does steam cleaning use real steam?

No. The machine uses hot water, sprayed into the carpet and vacuumed straight back out. Hot water extraction is the accurate name.

Is dry carpet cleaning really dry?

Not completely. Most of these methods use some liquid, only far less than a hot water rinse. Low-moisture is the more accurate name.

Which method do carpet warranties name?

The Shaw and Mohawk documents we read name hot water extraction. Warranties differ by product, so check your own and keep your receipts.

Is a truck-mounted machine always better than a portable one?

Not always. A truck mount can be faster on large jobs, but it cannot reach every home. In upper-floor units and some gated or high-rise buildings a portable machine is the practical choice.

Sources

Related services

Ready for cleaner carpet?

Call or send a request online. We confirm the day and time with you by phone.

CallBook